Why do people mourn famous animals they have never met? Perhaps the media, and increasingly social media, creates a sense of familiarity and personal connection with them.
Millions of people watched videos of Fiona the hippo at the Cincinnati Zoo as she was born in 2017, struggled to survive after being born prematurely and eventually grew into a playful animal weighing more than a ton with the help of dedicated zoo staff. When she died Thursday after apparently swallowing a child's hat in an accident, Cincinnati was plunged into grief. People around the world sought answers, while some attempted to assign blame.
"I miss her so much already," said Zee Azari, an emotional admirer who, like many visitors to the zoo on Friday, brought some of Fiona's favourite food and something with a familiar scent. "I brought a watermelon and some coffee today to remember her, so that she knew how much I loved her."
People are often surprised by the depth of grief they experience after losing a beloved pet. Studies have found that such sorrow can be as intense as mourning a human, even when the deceased is a famous animal that people have followed from a distance.
The sense of loss can also develop through virtual experiences, such as watching an animal's birth, struggle for survival and journey into adulthood online, as many did with Fiona. Such experiences can lead to what is known as disenfranchised grief — a significant loss that society or culture does not fully acknowledge or support.
'It just weighs so heavy'
Fiona would probably not have survived without the care of zoo staff. The zoo said her death was accidental. According to the institution, a child threw a hat into the air, and a ceiling fan blade sent it through a gap about a foot wide near the ceiling and into Fiona's enclosure. The hippo swallowed the hat but was unable to pass it through her body.
"It just weighs so heavy when we love these animals, even if we haven't met them," a woman identifying herself as Alice from Wales wrote on Reddit in a post shared with The Associated Press. "Their individual personalities shine through."
Along with affection for animals and concerns about conservation, their popularity raises complex questions about institutions that have kept wild animals in captivity for generations. These include concerns about animal exploitation, the human desire to connect with wildlife, ethical issues and the distinction between genuine conservation efforts and activities driven by mythology or profit.
Such animals have also helped raise substantial funds. Giant pandas, tigers, polar bears and elephants often serve as symbols for conservation organisations, attracting donations that can support broader efforts to protect habitats.
Fiona's death may offer parents an opportunity to discuss love and mortality with their children. It could also open a conversation about the continuing debate over keeping animals in captivity.
"There are all kinds of narratives at play here: Politics and privilege and visual culture and profit as much as agency on the part of the individual animals themselves. And animals don't have agency," said Huw Lewis-Jones, an associate professor of environment and culture at Falmouth University in Cornwall, England. "We want to look at them, we want to think about them. We certainly want to tell stories about them."
Animal celebrities have a long history
The practice of turning animals into celebrities dates back centuries, and some of their stories are complicated.
Fiona has long been associated with Harambe, the gorilla who was shot dead by zoo officials in 2016 after a young boy fell into his enclosure. Fiona was born six weeks prematurely the following year, and her unlikely survival helped ease the backlash over the zoo's handling of the incident. Her unrelated death this week at the same zoo has brought back painful memories for many.
Koko, the gorilla known for communicating through sign language, was another celebrated animal. She loved cats, reportedly understood death and could assess her own pain on a scale of one to 10. When she died in 2018 at the age of 46, people around the world mourned her as a connection between humans and other species. However, questions also remained about the ethics of exploiting animals and making them perform for public attention.
The original Shamu, a killer whale, died in 1971. SeaWorld continued using her name for its killer whale shows until 2016, when it announced plans to gradually end the programme following pressure from animal rights groups and environmentalists.
Some animal ambassadors, however, have captured public affection simply through their charm. Punch, a Japanese macaque orphaned in 2025, received a flood of birthday wishes from fans around the world when he turned one, despite having since made friends and no longer clinging to his toy.
In Southern California, many people know P-22, the region's most famous mountain lion. The animal was named after its designation as the 22nd puma in a National Park Service study. Wildlife cameras documented his search for a mate over a decade before he was found injured and euthanised in 2023. His story helped inspire the construction of a wildlife crossing over a highway near Los Angeles.
The bond people form with famous animals can last for years. In the case of Knautschke, a hippopotamus at the Berlin Zoo, his popularity also carried diplomatic significance.
Knautschke, a male hippo who survived World War II, became a symbol of resilience and remains well known today. During a special zoo tour earlier this year for people living with dementia, several participants recognised his bronze statue outside the current hippo enclosure.
Fiona was "the most effective zoo ambassador I believe there has ever been," her longtime keeper Jenna Wingate wrote on Instagram on Friday.
"She was magic," Wingate wrote, "wrapped in a hippo."