For the first time, United Nations climate negotiations are expected to acknowledge that the world must remove greenhouse gases from the atmosphere in addition to drastically cutting emissions, as efforts to prevent global warming from crossing a critical threshold have fallen short.
The proposed approach, however, could cost tens of trillions of dollars and depend on technologies that remain largely unproven. Scientists and UN officials say it may be the only available option to bring global temperatures back below the safety limit established under the 2015 Paris climate agreement.
Earlier this year, a UN annual report acknowledged that the world is certain to exceed the Paris Agreement's target of limiting long-term global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) above pre-industrial levels.
Short-term indicators have also raised concerns. October recorded the highest global average temperature above pre-industrial levels for any October, reaching 1.8 degrees Celsius (3.2 degrees Fahrenheit), according to scientists at Berkeley Earth. They also forecast that 2026 could surpass 2024 as the hottest year on record.
The UN climate negotiations, known as COP31, are scheduled to conclude on Friday in Turkey, although such conferences frequently extend beyond their official deadlines.
Early drafts of the conference's final statement recognise that the world has failed to prevent warming from exceeding 1.5 degrees Celsius and could face decades of higher temperatures before bringing them back below that threshold.
The drafts call for substantial reductions in carbon dioxide emissions alongside removing carbon already present in the atmosphere. Carbon dioxide released through burning fossil fuels such as coal, oil and gas traps heat and contributes to global warming.
Rob Jackson, a climate scientist at Stanford University and an emissions tracker, described carbon removal as a necessary option after the world exceeded its carbon budget for the 1.5-degree target.
He said removing carbon dioxide was technically possible but questioned whether the technology could be deployed on the scale of billions of tonnes required to make a meaningful difference.
Hundreds of billions of tonnes of carbon need to be removed
United Nations Environment Programme Director Inger Andersen said this week that the world would need to remove 320 billion metric tonnes (350 billion tons) of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere during this century to reverse the temperature trend.
She said the amount was equivalent to eight years of global emissions.
Berkeley Earth climate scientist Zeke Hausfather estimated that reducing global temperatures by every 0.1 degree Celsius (0.18 degrees Fahrenheit) through carbon removal would cost approximately $22 trillion.
Even under the most optimistic scenario, in which global temperatures peak 0.2 to 0.3 degrees Celsius (0.36 to 0.54 degrees Fahrenheit) above the Paris threshold, returning below the limit by 2100 could cost between $44 trillion and $66 trillion, he said.
Experts said expanding tree plantations would not be sufficient to remove the required amount of carbon. Over the past decade, increased tree planting and other nature-based solutions removed no more than two billion metric tonnes of carbon dioxide, according to Andersen.
Instead, scientists are looking towards mechanical technologies, including large installations equipped with giant fans designed to extract carbon dioxide directly from the air. Some of these technologies are currently being tested through pilot projects.
Johan Rockström, director of Germany's Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, said the emerging technology currently removes in an entire year roughly the amount of carbon dioxide that fossil fuel-burning power plants release in just 30 minutes.
However, he said there was hope that the technology could eventually expand to remove five billion metric tonnes annually by 2050.
This approach differs from carbon capture and storage technologies used by some industries to prevent their own emissions from entering the atmosphere. The climate negotiations are also expected to encourage wider use of such technologies.
Deep emission cuts remain the priority
Climate Analytics CEO Bill Hare said large-scale carbon removal would eventually be necessary, but warned that it should not distract governments from making substantial cuts in emissions.
He said there was little point in focusing on carbon removal without first achieving deep emission reductions.
Without changes in global climate policies, the world is heading towards at least 2.7 degrees Celsius of warming by 2100, he said, adding that no feasible level of carbon removal could compensate for such an increase.
Nevertheless, Andersen said countries must seriously consider removing carbon from the atmosphere because there were no favourable outcomes if global warming exceeded 1.5 degrees Celsius.
She noted that rising temperatures were already contributing to more severe heatwaves, droughts, floods and extreme storms.
Andersen and other officials stressed that carbon removal, sometimes referred to as negative emissions, should complement rather than replace substantial reductions in greenhouse gas emissions.
"We need deep emission reductions. That is, and will always remain, the most important tool at our disposal," said Denmark's Environment Minister Samira Nawa.
She said Denmark was pursuing a target of reducing emissions by 110%, going beyond net-zero emissions to achieve a situation in which the country removes 10% more carbon from the atmosphere than it releases, accounting for natural absorption by oceans and forests.
Denmark and Ethiopia, which will chair next year's UN climate conference, are leading a newly established coalition called the Group of Negative Emitters (GONE).
Scientists balance warnings with hope
Government officials, analysts and scientists say decades of inadequate action to reduce emissions have left the world facing an increasingly difficult climate challenge, making carbon removal an increasingly necessary option.
Melanie Robinson, global director of climate and economics at the World Resources Institute, said those advocating the 1.5-degree target must also recognise the need to achieve net-negative emissions.
Rockström acknowledged the challenges associated with removing carbon from the atmosphere but said the world must continue treating 1.5 degrees Celsius as its safe temperature limit, given the serious consequences of exceeding it.