A pulp mill in Washington state, where a chemical storage tank exploded in May, killing 11 workers, had a long history of serious safety violations, including neglecting inspections and repairs of more than a dozen other tanks at the facility, state investigators revealed on Friday.
Nippon Dynawave Packaging Co. is facing more than $10 million in state penalties, including the largest workplace safety fine ever imposed in Washington state. Investigators also plan to forward their findings to prosecutors to consider possible criminal charges.
According to the state investigation, the company had received several ultrasonic testing reports since 2025 indicating that the tank was unsafe for storing chemicals. However, it failed to repair the structure or remove it from operation, said Dan Pitts, compliance manager at the state Department of Labor and Industries, during a news conference in Longview.
Pitts said the tank's deteriorating walls posed an increasingly serious danger, warning that without necessary repairs or replacement, a catastrophic failure was inevitable.
In a statement issued Friday, Nippon said it was reviewing the state's findings. However, the company disputed investigators' description of its conduct as "egregious and willful," arguing that the assessment overlooked important facts and circumstances surrounding the incident.
The company said it would challenge the findings through the appropriate appeals process and stressed that the investigation should be completed before any final conclusions were made.
Nippon intends to resume mill operations in December. State authorities said the company must address all identified safety hazards and that officials would closely supervise its efforts to ensure compliance.
The May 26 accident killed 11 people and injured another 12 when a storage tank containing more than 900,000 gallons (3.4 million litres) of highly corrosive chemical known as white liquor ruptured. The substance is widely used in paper manufacturing. The powerful release damaged building walls and overturned pickup trucks at the facility.
Washington Labor and Industries Director Joel Sacks said the company knowingly continued operating the G-10 tank despite being aware of its unsafe condition, contributing to the deaths of 11 employees. He confirmed that the investigation's findings would be sent to prosecutors for consideration of criminal charges.
Meanwhile, the state Department of Ecology reported 34 environmental violations affecting air and water quality. It is seeking approximately $961,000 in penalties and emergency response costs.
Officials said most environmental violations resulted from the spread of white liquor across the mill premises. The chemical entered storm drains and the wastewater treatment system, with some reaching the Columbia River and a nearby ditch, resulting in fish deaths.
Investigation Reveals Wider Safety Failures
State investigators found that the company had failed to take appropriate measures to address known safety problems, violating state regulations. Similar inspection and maintenance failures were identified in 13 additional tanks at the facility.
The investigation also uncovered serious shortcomings in the company's emergency preparedness and response procedures. Employees had not received adequate preparation for handling emergencies, while an employer-led incident command system was absent for several hours following the tank rupture, Pitts said.
He added that weaknesses in the emergency response may have contributed to the serious injuries suffered by four of the 12 workers who were hurt.
Josh Estes, spokesperson for the Association of Western Pulp and Paper Workers union, said the organisation was examining the state's findings. He expressed anger that such serious safety warnings had allegedly been ignored and called for clear answers for the affected families. He also stressed that workers needed assurance that necessary safety improvements had been completed and verified.
The state investigation also supported findings from an August report by the U.S. Chemical Safety Board. That report revealed that company-appointed inspectors had determined in 2025 that the failed tank was unsuitable for continued operation because its walls had become dangerously thin.
Records Show Previous Safety and Environmental Violations
An Associated Press review of the mill's inspection records and workplace safety complaints found that the state Labor and Industries Department had investigated more than a dozen complaints involving the facility since 2018. The agency had imposed nearly $7,000 in fines for safety violations.
Separately, the Department of Ecology had issued 54 environmental violation notices against the company since 2016 and imposed $41,500 in fines for eight serious violations.
The agency also reported that workers' compensation payments exceeding $2.4 million had been made for 169 employees injured at the facility since 2015, including workers exposed to corrosive chemicals.
Following the May disaster, the Department of Ecology issued another violation notice against the company containing 35 citations.
In an email on Wednesday, Nippon Dynawave said it continued to cooperate with government agencies investigating the incident. The company noted that hundreds of visits by regulators and investigators had taken place at the mill.
It also said the complete dismantling, forensic inspection and technical examination of the damaged tank were still underway to establish the exact cause of the disaster. Parts of the structure were being carefully preserved for further analysis.
Families of Victims Seek Justice
Among those killed in the explosion were two brothers, Tyler and Brad Covington. Their mother, Sheri Lynn King, has filed a wrongful-death lawsuit against Nippon Dynawave.
The lawsuit alleges that her sons suffered fatal burns and crushing injuries from the chemical spill and falling debris. It further accuses the company of failing to properly inspect and maintain equipment, train and supervise employees, enforce workplace safety measures and establish effective emergency response procedures.
Kyle Findley, the lawyer representing King, welcomed the state's findings, saying workplace tragedies of this nature could be avoided if companies prioritised safety and took appropriate measures to protect employees.
He added that the family's legal battle would continue until justice was secured for the victims and those responsible were held accountable.